Current:Home > Contact-usNLRB official rules Dartmouth men's basketball team are employees, orders union vote-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
NLRB official rules Dartmouth men's basketball team are employees, orders union vote
View Date:2024-12-23 19:39:19
A regional director for the National Labor Relations Board on Monday ordered a union election for Dartmouth College men’s basketball players, writing that “because Dartmouth has the right to control the work performed by” the players and “because the players perform that work in exchange for compensation,” they are school employees under the National Labor Relations Act.
This the second time in the past 10 years that an National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) regional director has ordered a union election for athletes in a college sports program. And Monday’s ruling occurs as the NLRB’s Los Angeles office has another case pending against the University of Southern California, the Pac-12 Conference and the NCAA regarding employment status of football, men's basketball, women's basketball players.
The issue of college athletes’ employment status also if the focus of a federal court case pending with the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. And it has captured the attention of Congress, which is being lobbied heavily by the NCAA, conferences and schools to pass a bill that would prohibit athletes from being declared employees of schools because they play college sports.
In March 2014, a union election was ordered for the Northwestern football team, but the results were never made public. The university requested a review of the regional director’s ruling by the full NLRB, and in August 2015 the board declined to accept jurisdiction over the matter saying that because the board has no jurisdiction over public schools, addressing the Northwestern effort would run counter to the National Labor Relations Act’s charge that the board create stable and predictable labor environments in various industries.
Dartmouth can seek a similar review of Monday’s ruling, but – as in the Northwestern case – a player vote can be held in the meantime.
NLRB general counsel Jennifer Abruzzo, a Biden administration appointee, set the stage for the Dartmouth complaint when she issued a memo in September 2021 saying she views college athletes as employees of their schools under the National Labor Relations Act.
The complaint in the Dartmouth case was filed in September 2023, and a hearing was held in mid-October.
In Monday’s ruling, NLRB Regional Director Laura A. Sacks, wrote that the players “perform work which benefits Dartmouth. While there is some factual dispute as to how much revenue is generated by the men’s basketball program, and whether that program is profitable, the profitability of any given business does not affect the employee status of the individuals who perform work for that business.”
She also wrote that Dartmouth “exercises significant control over the basketball players’ work.” She said that Dartmouth’s student-athlete handbook “in many ways functions as an employee handbook.”
She cited several examples of the manner in which the university, its officials and its coaches make determinations of what the players can do and when. Many of the examples she cited are part of the routine for most college sports teams, although she noted that for Dartmouth players “special permission is required for a player to even get a haircut during a trip.”
According to the ruling, Dartmouth had argued that these types of regulations were necessary for players safety and “no different from the regulations placed on the student body at large.”
“However,” Sacks wrote, “the record reveals no evidence that other members of the student body (the vast majority of whom, like the basketball players at issue here, are presumably legal adults) are so strictly supervised when they leave the confines of Dartmouth’s campus.”
Sacks found that even though Dartmouth’s players do not receive athletic scholarships, they receive “compensation,” including special treatment in their quest for “highly coveted” acceptance to the prestigious school.
“The coaching staff is allotted a certain number of … admission spots for players they scout based upon their basketball skills,” she wrote, “and encourages players to matriculate at Dartmouth rather than at a school which might offer them an athletic scholarship because of the lifelong benefits that accrue to an alumnus of an Ivy League institution.”
veryGood! (44)
Related
- Driver dies after crashing on hurricane-damaged highway in North Carolina
- Judith Kimerling’s 1991 ‘Amazon Crude’ Exposed the Devastation of Oil Exploration in Ecuador. If Only She Could Make it Stop
- Logan Sargeant, the only American F1 driver, getting another shot in 2024 after tough rookie year
- Klete Keller, Olympic gold medalist, gets 36 months probation in Jan. 6 riot case
- In bizarro world, Tennessee plays better defense, and Georgia's Kirby Smart comes unglued
- BMW recalls SUVs after Takata air bag inflator blows apart, hurling shrapnel and injuring driver
- Are FTC regulators two weeks away from a decision on Kroger's $25B Albertsons takeover?
- These 15 Secrets About Big Little Lies Are What Really Happened
- Justice Department says jail conditions in Georgia’s Fulton County violate detainee rights
- In Dubai, Harris deals with 2 issues important to young voters: climate and Gaza
Ranking
- Deebo Samuel explains 'out of character' sideline altercation with 49ers long snapper, kicker
- AP Top 25: Michigan is No. 1 for first time in 26 seasons, Georgia’s streak on top ends at 24 weeks
- Man kills 4 relatives in Queens knife rampage, injures 2 officers before he’s fatally shot by police
- 'House of the Dragon' Season 2 first look: new cast members, photos and teaser trailer
- The Best Gifts for People Who Don’t Want Anything
- The Pentagon says a US warship and multiple commercial ships have come under attack in the Red Sea
- Harris focuses on shaping a post-conflict Gaza during a diplomatic blitz in Dubai with Arab leaders
- Why Kate Middleton Is Under More Pressure Than Most of the Royal Family
Recommendation
-
Mega Millions winning numbers for November 12 drawing: Jackpot rises to $361 million
-
Los Angeles police searching for suspect in three fatal shootings of homeless people
-
Widow of French serial killer who preyed on virgins admits to all the facts at trial
-
Indonesia’s Marapi volcano erupts, spewing ash plumes and blanketing several villages with ash
-
Tampa Bay Rays' Wander Franco arrested again in Dominican Republic, according to reports
-
Exclusive: MLB execs Billy Bean, Catalina Villegas – who fight for inclusion – now battle cancer
-
One dead and several injured after shooting at event in Louisiana
-
Exclusive: MLB execs Billy Bean, Catalina Villegas – who fight for inclusion – now battle cancer